【作者】 李超；

【导师】 王旭伟；

【作者基本信息】 沈阳师范大学 ， 法律（非法学）， 2021， 硕士

【副题名】辨析余金平交通肇事案

【摘要】 余金平交通肇事案一出,便引发了学术界关于此案轰轰烈烈的讨论,更有人称此案为中国的“马伯里诉麦迪逊案”,整个案子争议点众多,本文仅从总结的两个焦点性问题即:以检察院的视角对案件中认罪认罚从宽原则以及检方量刑建议方面进行系统研究。本文运用了案例分析法,通过刨析余金平交通肇事案,以检察院的角度,对法院的裁判文书和争议点进行分析,用余金平交通肇事案引入话题,在归纳本案的焦点性问题的同时,对适用认罪认罚从宽原则的前提和《刑事诉讼法》量刑建议方面进行了深入的探讨。并结合相关的法律法规,对本案中几个重要争议进行的解析。本文共分三个部分,第一章是案情简介及焦点性问题,主要对基本案例进行了介绍,并对案例中的两个焦点性问题:检方认罪认罚的把握以及量刑建议进行了归纳。第二章是针对检方认罪认罚,结合本案对认罪认罚的矛盾点,通过对认罪认罚中认罪的“如实供述”以及认罚中的量刑程度进行剖析。第三章是针对检察院的量刑建议的分析,阐述了在抗诉中检方为被告人利益的量刑建议所适用的原则以及《刑事诉讼法》第201条,结合本案,进行了综合阐述。最后结合案例,对焦点性问题进行概况和总结。更多还原

【Abstract】 As soon as Yu Jinping’s traffic accident case happened,it triggered a vigorous discussion in the academic circles.Some people called it "Marbury v.Madison case" in China.The whole case has a lot of controversy.This paper only summarizes the two focal issues: from the perspective of the procuratorate,the principle of lenient admission and punishment in the case and the prosecution’s sentencing suggestions are systematically studied.This paper uses the case analysis method to analyze Yu Jinping’s traffic accident case,analyzes the court’s judgment documents and controversial points from the perspective of the procuratorate,introduces the topic with Yu Jinping’s traffic accident case,and discusses the premise of applying the leniency principle of guilty plea and the sentencing suggestions in the Criminal Procedure Law while summarizing the focus of the case.Combined with relevant laws and regulations,this paper analyzes several important disputes in this case.the grasp of the prosecution’s confession and punishment and sentencing recommendations are summarized.The second chapter is for the prosecution to plead guilty,combined with the contradiction of this case,through the "true confession" and the degree of sentencing in the confession.The third chapter is the analysis of the Procuratorate’s sentencing recommendations,expounds the principles of sentencing recommendations for the interests of the defendant in the protest and Article 201 of the criminal procedure law,and makes a comprehensive elaboration based on this case.Finally,the focus of the problem is summarized with a case study.更多还原