节点文献
第三人过错所致旅行社违约责任研究
On the Travel Agency’s Liability for Breaching the Contract Due to the Third Party’s Fault
【作者】 李芳;
【导师】 李先波;
【作者基本信息】 湖南师范大学 , 民商法, 2010, 硕士
【摘要】 随着社会经济的飞速发展,人们生活水平的不断提高,旅游业也得到了迅猛发展,与此同时旅游纠纷的数量日益增多。由于我国规范旅游市场的法律几乎是一片空白,导致旅游合同中旅行社的责任难以界定,使得旅游合同纠纷难以顺利解决。尤其是在旅游合同的履行中,旅行社不可能亲自完成所有给付,不可避免地使用第三人(旅游服务提供人)来完成旅游给付,由于第三人的原因造成旅游给付瑕疵时,旅行社应该承担何种责任,这就需要相关的法律制度予以规范。各国立法对因第三人过错导致旅行社违约责任予以规范的目的主要为:一是保证旅游市场地顺利发展;二是充分保护旅游消费者的合法权益;三是有利于平衡旅行社的利益。因此,因第三人过错所致旅行社违约责任的研究反映出一种价值取向,必须从法律规制层面入手。旅行社违约责任是指旅游合同中旅行社不履行合同义务或履行合同义务不符合合同约定依法产生的法律责任。本文中旅行社的违约责任是因第三人的过错造成对旅游者的违约而承担的法律责任。在行文上,以界定第三人过错所致旅行社违约责任的内涵为起点,阐述了第三人过错所致旅行社违约责任的归责原则、构成要件、责任承担和免责事由,通过比较分析域外第三人过错所致旅行社违约责任法律制度的先进立法例以及立法分析,并探讨了我国有关第三人过错所致旅行社违约责任的立法与司法现状,得出因第三人过错所致旅行社违约责任的责任承担方面的启示。因第三人过错所致旅行社违约责任研究的创新之处主要有:是提出完善我国因第三人过错所致旅行社违约责任的立法建议,主张在旅游合同有名化的基础上,设立旅行社为第三人负责制,适用严格责任规制因第三人过错所致旅行社违约问题,并引进旅行社责任限制制度,以保护旅行社的合理发展。二是明示了必须运用比较分析法、综合归纳法等研究方法,对第三人过错所致旅行社违约责任进行研究、分析,以期进一步保护旅游者的合法权利,有利于规范旅游市场,有利于促进我国未来的旅游合同立法。
【Abstract】 With the rapid development of the social economic and the rise of people’s living standard, the tourism has also developed rapidly, at the same time the number of disputes on tourism is increasing. Because our country has no law to regulate the tourism market, leading travel agencies’responsibility in the contract is difficult to define and making disputes of travel contract is difficult to resolve smoothly. Especially in the performance of tourism contract, the travel agency can’t possibly complete all the payments, and inevitably make the third party (the travel service provider) to complete the travel payments. When the third party causes defective travel payment, what degree of responsibility does the travel agent should bear? It requires that the relevant legal system to regulate these questions.The main purpose, that all countries’legislation regulates the travel agency’breach of contract which is caused by the third party’s fault, as follows:First, to ensure the smooth development of the tourism market; Second, to protect the tourism consumers’legal rights and interests sufficiently; Third, to be beneficial to balance the travel agencies’ benefits. Therefore, the study on travel agencies’responsibility for breaching the contract due to the third party’fault reflects a value orientation, that is we must start from the legal regulation. The travel agency’s liability for breaching the contract is the legal liability caused by the travel agency in the tourism contract when the travel agency doesn’t perform the contractual obligations or doesn’t perform the contractual obligations in accordance with the conformity of the contract. The travel agency’s liability for breaching the contract here is the legal responsibility for tourists by the breach of contract due to the fault of a third party. This article, defines the connotation of the travel agency’s liability for breaching the contract due to the third party’s fault as the starting point, and explains the responsibility and exemption of the travel agency’s liability for breaching the contract caused by the fault of a third party, and compare and analysis other countries’advanced legislation on the travel agency’s liability for breaching the contract due to the third party’s fault as well as cases of reference to China, and explore the legislative and the judicial status on the travel agency’s liability for breaching the contract due to the third party’s fault in our country, and get the bearing responsibility’s revelation on the travel agency’s liability for breaching the contract due to the third party’s fault.The innovations on the travel agency’s liability for breaching the contract due to the third party’s fault are follows:First, suggesting legislative proposals of improving the travel agency’s liability for breaching the contract due to the third party’s fault in our country, and advocating the establishment of the travel agencies’responsibility for the third party, and applying the strict liability to regulate the issues on the travel agencies’breach of contract, and inducting the limited liability regime for the travel agencies, in order to protect travel agencies’ rational development; Second, expressing that we must use the comparative analysis method, integrated research method and other research methods to research and analysis the travel agency’s liability for breaching the contract due to the third party’s fault, with a view to further protect the legitimate rights of tourists, and to be helpful to regulate the tourism market, and to promote the China’s legislation of the travel contract in the future.
【Key words】 The third party’s fault; Travel agency; Liability of breaching the contract;