民事诉讼瑕疵书证研究

【作者】 徐龙震；

【导师】 李浩；

【作者基本信息】 南京师范大学 ， 诉讼法学， 2007， 硕士

【摘要】 瑕疵书证是民事诉讼实践中经常遇到的特殊书证问题，但由于出现瑕疵的情况复杂多样、琐细微小，各国立法大多未对此给予详细规定，理论研究也较为薄弱。实际上，瑕疵书证是一个重要的理论和实践问题，瑕疵的存在使书证的证明力受到影响，成为当事人证明主张和法官查明事实的障碍，不研究其存在现象，就无法认识其一般规律。本文从书证基础理论入手，分析了瑕疵书证的定义、特点、产生原因、分类等一般性理论问题，结合典型案例分析了在司法实践中瑕疵书证的常见形态，从比较法角度介绍了域外在瑕疵书证问题上的立法状况，最后，分析了当事人对瑕疵书证的预防、运用技术及法官对瑕疵书证证明力的审查判断等问题。更多还原

【Abstract】 Defective documentary evidence often comes across in civil action, which appears various, complicated and tiny, so most country’s legislation and theory have not regulated in detail. In fact, as an important theoretical and practical issue, defective documentary evidence affects its probative force and become obstacles to party’s testify activity and judge’s adjudgement. If we don’t study its phenomenon, we have no way to know its general law. From basic theory of documentary evidence, this paper analyses definition, characteristic, cause and classify of defective documentary evidence, study several kinds of it in practice, introduce legislation status at home and abroad, finally, analyses that parties apply and take precautions against it and that judges estimate its probative force, etc.更多还原