Through the two counter-examples: Dark Tourismand Spiritual Tourismand with the theories,such as existentialism,transcendentalism of Maslow's hierarchy of needs,implicative ontology,this paper questions the viewpoints put forward by Professor XIE Yanjun: Tourism is a off-site leisure experience for the purpose of pleasure,and shows that the conclusion of the essence of tourism determined by experience and pleasure is over generalized and imperfect,and the pleasure experience of tourism can only explains the...