节点文献

行为概念与行为体系的重新界定——以不作为犯罪为研究对象

The Re-definition of Conduct Concept and Conduct System——Take the Criminal Omission for Research Object

  • 推荐 CAJ下载
  • PDF下载
  • 不支持迅雷等下载工具,请取消加速工具后下载。

【作者】 田旭

【Author】 Tian Xu;Criminal Law Science Research Institute,Beijing Normal University;

【机构】 北京师范大学刑事法律科学研究院

【摘要】 "无行为则无犯罪"的适用存在局限性,其是对纯粹思想入罪的否定,不能据此认为只有"存在行为"才"存在犯罪",当刑法命令人们必须实施某种特定行为时,不存在特定行为的不作为反而会成立犯罪。将具有社会意义视为行为概念的认定标准,取得了形式上的统一,但也造成了行为概念的空洞化。不作为犯罪规定的并不是一种有害行为,而是一种有益行为的不存在状态,该行为并不是促使危害结果发生的"原因",而是制止危害结果产生的"阻却条件"。不作为犯罪违反命令规范,以定型之有益行为的不存在来彰显不法,作为犯罪违反禁止规范,以定型之有害行为的存在来彰显不法,二者在客观上为两种互斥的事实状态,两种规范则表明了实现犯罪的两种不同途径。行为只能是人事实地控制客观条件而作用于具体的人或物之存在状态的现实过程,社会事实才是能够同时涵盖作为与不作为的上位概念,行为则是作为与不作为共同内涵的下位概念,其通过宣示"何种行为成立犯罪"来明确不法路径或者宣示"何种行为不成立犯罪"来明确合法路径。划定罪与非罪的界限是行为作为刑法中基础概念的核心功能。

【Abstract】 "No conduct,no crime" has its own limitations, it is the negation on Ruling thought as a crime, so we could not arrival at a conclusion that only a conduct could constitute a crime. When the criminal law requires people to implement some particular conduct, non existing conduct means existing a crime. The way of making the social significance as the identification standard of conduct results to the nihility of conduct concept. What the criminal omission provides is not a harmful conduct, but the nothingness of a beneficial conduct. The conduct is not the reason which causes the harmful consequences, but the condition which prevents the occurrence of the harmful consequences. The criminal omission violates the norms of command, and the nothingness of beneficial conduct embodies the illegality. The action crime violates the norms of prohibition, and the existence of harmful conduct embodies the illegality. They are two mutually exclusive objective-state, and also two basic ways of implementing crime. The conduct could only be the realistic process that people control the objective conditions to make them act on the specific persons or things, and the social fact is the superior concept which contains both the action and the omission, and the conduct is the sub-concept contained by both the action and the omission. Through declaring that "what behavior establishes a crime" to confirm the illegal path or "what behavior does not establish a crime" to confirm the legal path, the conduct could make a clear distinction between crime and non-crime, and that is the core function of the conduct as the basic concept of criminal law.

【关键词】 作为不作为行为概念行为体系
【Key words】 ActionOmissionConduct conceptConduct system
  • 【文献出处】 甘肃行政学院学报 ,Journal of Gansu Administration Institute , 编辑部邮箱 ,2015年05期
  • 【分类号】D924.3
  • 【被引频次】1
  • 【下载频次】321
节点文献中: 

本文链接的文献网络图示:

本文的引文网络