节点文献
阿多诺:“表达不可表达的东西”——从“作为他者的物”到不可知论的“历史唯物主义”
Adorno: "Expressing the Inexpressible Matter" : From "the Matter of the Other" to the Agnostic "Historical Materialism"
【摘要】 阿多诺的"他者"是一种不能被主体"我"用概念所认知和吞噬的"异质性",也就是"物"。因此"物"就是"非概念物"。因为阿多诺继承了康德"物自体不可知"的观点,所以"非概念物"成了他抵抗唯心主义认识论的唯一武器。"否定的辩证法"认为,"物"与"我"永远处于不可统一的中介关系当中,这在本质上是把黑格尔的中介思想贯彻到底的结果。在此基础上,阿多诺认为,是这个不可知的"物"的运动导致了历史的发生,所以历史本身也是不可知的。所以,言说"物"和"历史",都是在"表达不可表达的东西"。总之,阿多诺是从"作为他者的物"推论出了不可知论的"历史唯物主义"。从这个意义上讲,哈贝马斯的交往行动理论应该属于广义的否定辩证法。
【Abstract】 Adorno’s "the other" is a "heterogeneity" that cannot be cognized and swallowed by the concept of subject "I".That is the "matter".So "matter" is namely the "non-conceptual matter".Because Adorno inherited Kant’s opinion that "do not know the thing in itself", "non-conceptual matter" became the only weapon to stand up to the idealist epistemology. "Negative dialectics" believes that "matter" and "I" are always in a certain medium condition that cannot be unified,which is the result that carrying out Hegel’s medium thought through to the end.On this basis,Adorno believes that it is the moving of the unknowable matter that leads to the happening of history,so history itself is unknowable,too.Therefore,talking about "matter" or "history" is "expressing the inexpressible matter".In a word,Adorno deduces the agnostic "historical materialism" from "the matter of the other".In this sense,Habermas’ theory of communicative action belongs to generalized negative dialectics theory.
【Key words】 the other; heterogeneity; unknowable; non-conceptual matter; medium; Adorno;
- 【文献出处】 浙江社会科学 ,Zhejiang Social Sciences , 编辑部邮箱 ,2013年12期
- 【分类号】B089.1
- 【被引频次】6
- 【下载频次】376