节点文献
论刑事诉讼中瑕疵证据的概念与特征
On Concept and Characteristics of Slight Defected Evidence in Criminal Proceedings
【摘要】 瑕疵证据已成为刑事诉讼中的一个热门话题。但是,由于某些研究过于强调"中国的司法国情",过分追求实然效果,忽略了从证据法学的理论对瑕疵证据作出严谨的逻辑论证,从而导致有关瑕疵证据的基本定位出现偏差、概念界定不清、特征描述混乱。其实,瑕疵证据属于不适格证据中的一种形式,其主要解决证据能力问题,而判断证据能力的标准是证据的客观性、关联性与合法性。因此,证据的三个属性才是瑕疵证据研究的逻辑起点。
【Abstract】 Slight defective evidence has become a hot topic in criminal proceedings.However,in related researches "judicial situations in China" is excessively stressed.So some researchers pursuit practical effect extravagantly and neglected strict logical argumentation of slight defective evidence in evidence law perspective.The outcomes are:deviation from basic defected evidence position,vagueness of concept definition,and confusion on characteristic description.In fact,slight defected evidence is a kind of evidences which are unsuitable.It solves evidence capability.And the distinction standard of evidence capability is 3 kinds of evidence attributes:objectivity,relevance,and validity.So only these 3 evidence attributes are the logic starting points of the slight defected evidence research.
【Key words】 defective evidence evidence attribute evidence capability probative force;
- 【文献出处】 法学杂志 ,Law Science Magazine , 编辑部邮箱 ,2012年11期
- 【分类号】D925.23
- 【被引频次】44
- 【下载频次】1634