【摘要】 《在科学与艺术之间———质疑国际关系理论》一文虽然提出了一些具有一定学术价值的问题 ,对国际关系理论提出了一些具有一定原创性的批评 ,但文章违背了学术批判的基本原则 ,在逻辑推断和事实运用上也存在问题 ,从而直接削弱了文章的科学性和说服力 ,使批判失去了本应具有的推动学术进步的功能。更多还原

【Abstract】 In this critical review of "Between Science and Art: On a Theory of International Relations" written by Wang Yiwei, the author argues that despite some interesting points and comments, Wang’s paper does not follow the fundamental principles of academic criticism. As a result, the argument in the paper suffers from a weakness of logic and a lack of evidence. These problems undermine the persuasiveness of the paper, which in turn limits its contribution to a clarification of academic issues.更多还原