【摘要】 本文评价了江蛰君《论水浒戏》一文多方面的学术价值 :肯定江文辨明了两类水浒戏曲彼此间对立的政治倾向 ;理清了水浒戏曲、话本与《水浒传》小说产生的过程 ,赞扬了歌颂起义英雄的水浒戏 ,批判了丑化农民起义的水浒戏 ,并对金圣叹腰斩《水浒》持基本肯定态度 ;与此同时 ,本文作者还对 4 3集电视剧《水浒》的主题方面出现的问题提出了批评更多还原

【Abstract】 This paper makes a review of ecademic values of Mr.Jiang zhijun’s "on Traditional operas of ’water Margin’ " It affirms that Jiang distingnishes the political attitudes reflected in two kinds of operas, makes clear the formative processes of operas, scripts and the book "water Margin", highlights the operas which sung praise of heroes ,criticizes the operas which vilified the peasant prising,and holds a positive view about jin shentan’s re-editing of ’water Margin’.In addition,the author makes some comments on the themes of Tv series of"water Margin".更多还原